services: add --keep flag

Library/Homebrew/cmd/services.rb

@@ -38,8 +38,9 @@ module Homebrew
           [`sudo`] `brew services start` (<formula>|`--all`|`--file=`):
           Start the service <formula> immediately and register it to launch at login (or boot).
 
-          [`sudo`] `brew services stop` (<formula>|`--all`):
+          [`sudo`] `brew services stop` (`--keep`) (`--no-wait`|`--max-wait=`) (<formula>|`--all`):
-          Stop the service <formula> immediately and unregister it from launching at login (or boot).
+          Stop the service <formula> immediately and unregister it from launching at login (or boot),
+          unless `--keep` is specified.
 
           [`sudo`] `brew services kill` (<formula>|`--all`):
           Stop the service <formula> immediately but keep it registered to launch at login (or boot).
@@ -57,6 +58,7 @@ module Homebrew
         switch "--all", description: "Run <subcommand> on all services."
         switch "--json", description: "Output as JSON."
         switch "--no-wait", description: "Don't wait for `stop` to finish stopping the service."
+        switch "--keep", description: "When stopped, don't unregister the service from launching at login (or boot)."
         conflicts "--max-wait=", "--no-wait"
         named_args
       end
@@ -117,6 +119,14 @@ module Homebrew
           end
         end
 
+        unless Homebrew::Services::Commands::Stop::TRIGGERS.include?(subcommand)
+          raise UsageError, "The `#{subcommand}` subcommand does not accept the --keep argument!" if args.keep?
+          raise UsageError, "The `#{subcommand}` subcommand does not accept the --no-wait argument!" if args.no_wait?
+          if args.max_wait
+            raise UsageError, "The `#{subcommand}` subcommand does not accept the --max-wait= argument!"
+          end
+        end
+
         opoo "The --all argument overrides provided formula argument!" if formulae.present? && args.all?
 
         targets = if args.all?
@@ -162,8 +172,13 @@ module Homebrew
         when *Homebrew::Services::Commands::Start::TRIGGERS
           Homebrew::Services::Commands::Start.run(targets, args.file, verbose: args.verbose?)
         when *Homebrew::Services::Commands::Stop::TRIGGERS
-          max_wait = args.max_wait.to_f
+          Homebrew::Services::Commands::Stop.run(
-          Homebrew::Services::Commands::Stop.run(targets, verbose: args.verbose?, no_wait: args.no_wait?, max_wait:)
+            targets,
+            verbose:  args.verbose?,
+            no_wait:  args.no_wait?,
+            max_wait: args.max_wait.to_f,
+            keep:     args.keep?,
+          )
         when *Homebrew::Services::Commands::Kill::TRIGGERS
           Homebrew::Services::Commands::Kill.run(targets, verbose: args.verbose?)
         else

Library/Homebrew/services/cli.rb

@@ -159,12 +159,13 @@ module Homebrew
           verbose:  T::Boolean,
           no_wait:  T::Boolean,
           max_wait: T.nilable(T.any(Integer, Float)),
+          keep:     T::Boolean,
         ).void
       }
-      def self.stop(targets, verbose: false, no_wait: false, max_wait: 0)
+      def self.stop(targets, verbose: false, no_wait: false, max_wait: 0, keep: false)
         targets.each do |service|
           unless service.loaded?
-            rm service.dest if service.dest.exist? # get rid of installed service file anyway, dude
+            rm service.dest if !keep && service.dest.exist? # get rid of installed service file anyway, dude
             if service.service_file_present?
               odie <<~EOS
                 Service `#{service.name}` is started as `#{service.owner}`. Try:
@@ -188,7 +189,11 @@ module Homebrew
           end
 
           if System.systemctl?
-            System::Systemctl.quiet_run(*systemctl_args, "disable", "--now", service.service_name)
+            if keep
+              System::Systemctl.quiet_run(*systemctl_args, "stop", service.service_name)
+            else
+              System::Systemctl.quiet_run(*systemctl_args, "disable", "--now", service.service_name)
+            end
           elsif System.launchctl?
             quiet_system System.launchctl, "bootout", "#{System.domain_target}/#{service.service_name}"
             unless no_wait
@@ -204,9 +209,11 @@ module Homebrew
             quiet_system System.launchctl, "stop", "#{System.domain_target}/#{service.service_name}" if service.pid?
           end
 
-          rm service.dest if service.dest.exist?
+          unless keep
-          # Run daemon-reload on systemctl to finish unloading stopped and deleted service.
+            rm service.dest if service.dest.exist?
-          System::Systemctl.run(*systemctl_args, "daemon-reload") if System.systemctl?
+            # Run daemon-reload on systemctl to finish unloading stopped and deleted service.
+            System::Systemctl.run(*systemctl_args, "daemon-reload") if System.systemctl?
+          end
 
           if service.pid? || service.loaded?
             opoo "Unable to stop `#{service.name}` (label: #{service.service_name})"

Library/Homebrew/services/commands/stop.rb

@@ -15,11 +15,12 @@ module Homebrew
             verbose:  T::Boolean,
             no_wait:  T::Boolean,
             max_wait: T.nilable(Float),
+            keep:     T::Boolean,
           ).void
         }
-        def self.run(targets, verbose:, no_wait:, max_wait:)
+        def self.run(targets, verbose:, no_wait:, max_wait:, keep:)
           Services::Cli.check(targets)
-          Services::Cli.stop(targets, verbose:, no_wait:, max_wait:)
+          Services::Cli.stop(targets, verbose:, no_wait:, max_wait:, keep:)
         end
       end
     end

Library/Homebrew/sorbet/rbi/dsl/homebrew/cmd/services.rbi

@@ -20,6 +20,9 @@ class Homebrew::Cmd::Services::Args < Homebrew::CLI::Args
   sig { returns(T::Boolean) }
   def json?; end
 
+  sig { returns(T::Boolean) }
+  def keep?; end
+
   sig { returns(T.nilable(String)) }
   def max_wait; end